Pierre Bordieu: The New Capital

Bordieu discusses how families invest in their children’s education’s because the relative weight of their cultural capital is greater than their economic capital. Students who have parents who are privileged or are intellectuals attend the best schools, so they get the best social positions, which effectively creates a monopoly on success. Bordieu uses a metaphor of a demon sorting students based on their cultural capital to illustrate how some students are selected to move forward in the education system based on nothing other than their cultural capital. Cultural capital does not determine success in education, but students who have high amounts of cultural capital are selected , thus continuing the pattern of preexisting social differences. Bordieu states that students who receive education at exclusive universities are predestined for success and are comparable to nobility.  According to Bordieu, the education system only reinforces privilege instead of allowing people to overcome  this “hereditary privilege”  through merit.

This picture illustrates how the child of wealthy parents  is guaranteed success, not because of his merit, but because his parents can afford the best opportunities for him. A child with similar potential, but less cultural and/or economic capital will be denied the same privileges due to the inequality in our education system.

tandberg: i can see a big future ... The Age 16th April 2008

Communication Boundaries

Goffman describes the physical and social boundaries that exist in  communication. Communication can be separated by physical boundaries such as walls and doors, which social convention dictates that people refrain from joining  by crossing these physical boundaries. When people are involved in accessible engagements, or encounters that occur, face to face,  they are divided socially into bystanders and participants. The bystanders are expected to follow social cues in order to tactfully join the conversation to become participants. Spacing occurs when people communicating distribute themselves cooperatively in the available space to create conventional closure which ensures open “talk lines” so that people can address one another without obstruction. Sound control establishes the proper volume that people will talk at, which is determined by the social setting they are present in. These requirements set a limit to the distance that communications can occur. Sound control and spacing must be present for a conversation to be considered proper.

 

These people are spaced so there is open talk lines between the three of them and they are talking at a level that is appropriate for their setting.

8148293-business-people-talking-to-each-other-outdoors

 

These people have violated the communication boundaries and must be restrained.

Communication2

Theses Statements and Statements

Gentrification can revitalize urban neighborhoods.  However, gentrification is ultimately negative for a community because it leads to a loss of culture and the homogenization of diverse neighborhoods.

Gentrification can provide positives, but gentrification is ultimately negative for a neighborhood because original residents are displaced, conflict between new residents and original residents arises over changes to the neighborhood and the original identity of community is lost.

Gentrification is a politically motivated process that marginalizes low-income members of the community because it caters to new, wealthier citizens for revenue gains.  Gentrification leaves the original members of the community with a lack of political support to respond to the changes occurring.

Sources:

1.  Auger, Deborah. “The Politics of Revitalization in Gentrifying Neighborhoods

2. The Case of Boston’s South End.” Journal of the American Planning Association 45.4 (1979): 515-22. Print.

3.  Brown-Saracino, Japonica.  A Neighborhood That Never Changes: Gentrification,

4.Social Preservation, and the Search for Authenticity. Chicago: University of Chicago, 2009. 51-80. Print.

5. Sharon Zukin Annual Review of Sociology , Vol. 13, (1987) , pp. 129-147

The Structure of Social Groups

Bureaucracy is a form of administration used to increase organization and efficiency. Bureaucracy is used in both the private and public sectors to increase productivity by clearly defining roles and jobs for each member of the bureaucracy. Bureaucracy is important to sociology and sociological understanding because it enforces a hierarchal role in society. With bureaucracy there is a clear chain of command and power flows from the top down. George Ritzer called the increased presence of bureaucracy in society “McDonaldization” because the specific expectations and rules exclude creativity and create a “blind obedience” to rules. This strict adherence to procedure can be dangerous to people and society  because people fail to respond to situations that occur outside of the standard operating procedure.

Bureaucracy Meme1

Psychologist Solomon Asch conducted experiments testing the degree of influence that social groups have on individuals. Asch found that in a group, the desire to conform is so strong that individuals would rather give incorrect responses to questions they know the correct answer to than give an response that differs from the group.

Conformity Asch Meme

 

 

For my research topic I would like to study the effect that social movements have on political policy.

Class Consciousness

The concept that I chose to explore from the reading was class consciousness, because I find Marx’s ideas about class warfare to be interesting. Marx believed that when the working class developed class consciousness or “recognized their class interests, common oppression and an understanding of who their oppressors are,” (Eitzen, Bacazinn and Smith, 9) they would organize a revolt against the current social system. This concept is important to sociology and a sociological understanding of society because it can explain why some people are unhappy with their social status and the ways they try to seek reform. A few ways that this concept helps me to understand society better are because class consciousness also can be used to explain peoples motivation to elevate their social status.  When individuals realize that they belong to a lower social class, they are motived to try to increase their status in society.  Achieving a high social class is a goal of many people in our capitalist society and can partly be explained by class consciousness.

 

 

 

I created two memes that help explain this concept:

meme 3